Best Italian Restaurants on Maui: A Local's Guide

It's a quarter past six in Wailea and the light is doing the thing it does — turning the ocean to hammered gold while the last paddleboarders drift home. On the table: a bowl of pappardelle with short rib ragu, a glass of Barolo, and a warm breeze that no restaurant in Rome can plate. Somewhere between the second bite and the sunset, you stop wondering whether Italian food belongs on a Pacific island.

It does — and better than most first-time visitors expect. Maui's Italian scene runs from white-tablecloth osterias overlooking Wailea Beach to a family bakery in Kihei that sells out of cannoli by mid-afternoon, up to a Makawao institution that has been feeding Upcountry paniolo country since the 1980s. The through-line is ingredients: fresh island fish, Upcountry vegetables, and herbs that grew twenty minutes from your table, all run through recipes that reward simplicity. Here's where to point the rental car when the pasta craving hits.

Golden hour in Wailea: the house wine pairing no other Italian restaurant can pour.

Wailea: Oceanfront Italian at Its Most Polished

If you're staying along the Wailea resort coast, you can walk or take a five-minute drive to some of the best Italian meals in Hawai'i. This is the splurge end of the spectrum — the kind of dinners people plan anniversaries around.

Ferraro's Bar e Ristorante at the Four Seasons Resort Maui is the one everyone pictures: open-air tables terraced above Wailea Beach, live music drifting through the plumeria, and a menu that treats island fish with Italian restraint. Lunch is casual and ocean-breezy; dinner is a full production, and the sunset seating goes first. You don't need to be a resort guest — you just need a reservation, ideally booked well before your trip.

Matteo's Osteria on Wailea Ike Drive is the local favorite in the neighborhood — a chef-owned osteria and wine bar where the pasta is made in-house and the wine list runs deep into small Italian producers. The vibe is polished but unstuffy: bar seats for a plate of carbonara and a glass of Nebbiolo, or a proper table for the tasting-style dinner. It shows up on our list of romantic restaurants on Maui for good reason.

Longhi's at the Shops at Wailea is the old-school institution — an Italian-influenced Maui original that has been serving prawns amaretto and steaks since the 1970s era of island dining. It's breezy, generous, and unapologetically classic. A few doors down, Manoli's Pizza Company covers the casual end of Wailea: hand-tossed pies, happy hour deals, and a lanai with an ocean peek — a genuinely useful option when half the table wants pizza and the other half wants a proper glass of wine.

Local's Tip: For Ferraro's, ask for a table on the lower terrace about an hour before sunset — you get the full color show over Wailea Beach and the live musicians without the mid-dinner glare. Book two to three weeks out in high season.

House-made daily: Wailea's osterias roll their pasta the old way.

Kihei: Casual, Family-Run & Worth the Line

Kihei's Italian anchor is Fabiani's Bakery & Pizza — a family-run spot that manages to be a legitimate Italian bakery, a thin-crust pizzeria, and a neighborhood pasta house all at once. Locals hit the Lipoa Street original for breakfast pastries and espresso, come back at lunch for pizza by the pie, and settle in at dinner for gnocchi and osso buco at prices that undercut the resort corridor by a comfortable margin. There's a second, slightly dressier location at Wailea Gateway if you're staying south.

The move most visitors miss: Fabiani's to-go. A boxed pizza, a container of tiramisu, and a bottle of Chianti from the shop next door turns any South Maui condo lanai into a private trattoria — no corkage, no dress code, sunset included. It's a standing entry in our guide to the best restaurants on Maui for exactly this kind of flexibility.

Local's Tip: Fabiani's cannoli and cream puffs sell out most afternoons. If dessert matters to you — and on vacation it should — swing by before 2 p.m. and stash them in your rental's fridge for later.

Kihei's answer to the resort corridor: blistered crust, honest prices.

Beyond South Maui: Upcountry & West Side Classics

Casanova Italian Restaurant & Deli in Makawao is the island's great Italian institution — a paniolo-town landmark where Upcountry ranchers, artists, and visitors have shared wood-fired pizzas and house pastas for decades. The attached deli does espresso and panini by day; the dining room does serious Northern Italian by night; and on weekend nights the back room becomes one of Maui's liveliest dance floors. Pair it with a Makawao gallery stroll and you've built a perfect Upcountry evening.

On the west side, Taverna in Kapalua brings coastal Italian — crudo, house pastas, negronis on tap — to golf-course views at the island's northwest corner. And back Upcountry in Pukalani, Marlow is the newer star: chef-driven, naturally leavened wood-fired pies and seasonal plates built almost entirely from Maui-grown ingredients. Both are destination-worthy if your day already points that direction; from a South Maui base, they're best folded into a day trip rather than a dedicated dinner drive.

Local's Tip: Casanova's wood-fired pizzas and live-music nights are a combo — check their calendar and aim for a Friday or Saturday. Makawao is about 40 minutes from Kihei, and the drive home under Upcountry stars is part of the experience.

The Vacation Rental Pasta Night: Cook It Yourself

Here's the quiet advantage of staying in a vacation rental instead of a resort room: one night, skip the reservation entirely. Saturday morning, hit the Upcountry farmers market or the Kihei fish counters for fresh ono or mahi; grab Kula tomatoes, local basil, and a wedge of parmesan; and cook the simplest Italian dinner of your life in a condo with a full kitchen. Fish seared in olive oil, pasta with raw-tomato sauce, and a sunset off the lanai — total cost, roughly one resort appetizer.

It's also the perfect counterweight to the splurge nights. Most of our guests settle into a rhythm: one or two big dinners out — Ferraro's, Matteo's, or something from our Maui fine dining guide — and the rest of the week trading between casual spots and home-cooked meals. The kitchen is what makes a week of great eating sustainable, for both your budget and your appetite.

Local's Tip: Kula-grown strawberries plus mascarpone from the grocery store equals a five-minute dessert that outperforms most restaurant tiramisu. Thank us later.

The best table on the island might be the one on your own lanai.

Planning Your Italian Nights: Reservations, Timing & Dress

A little strategy goes a long way here, because Maui's best Italian tables book the way its best sunsets photograph — fast. For the marquee dinners, make reservations before you fly: Ferraro's sunset window disappears two to three weeks out in high season, and Matteo's better tables go nearly as quickly on weekends. Mid-week is your friend everywhere — a Tuesday at Matteo's feels like a private wine dinner, while the same room on Saturday hums at full volume.

Timing matters more than most visitors expect. Maui dines early; the island's rhythm runs on sunrise hikes and snorkel mornings, so 5:30 to 7 p.m. is prime time and a 8:15 table is often the easiest to land — and comes with a quieter room and an unhurried kitchen. Sunset shifts through the year, too: in summer it lands close to 7:15, in winter closer to 5:50, so match your reservation to the show you want. As for dress, 'resort casual' covers everything on this list — collared shirt or an aloha shirt and you're overdressed for Fabiani's and exactly right for Ferraro's. Nobody on Maui owns a dinner jacket, including the people serving you.

Two budget notes worth knowing. First, happy hour is the back door into the expensive rooms: Manoli's and several Wailea bars run genuinely good late-afternoon windows where a wood-fired pizza and a glass of Italian red cost half the dinner tab. Second, lunch at the splurge spots delivers most of the view at a fraction of the price — Ferraro's midday menu comes with the same beach panorama, minus the candlelight and about a third of the bill.

Local's Tip: Celebrating something? Say so when you book, not when you arrive. Maui's Italian kitchens are romantics at heart — anniversaries and proposals get the corner tables, the extra dessert, and occasionally the musicians drifting over — but only if they know you're coming.

Where to Stay for Maui's Best Italian Food

Look at the map and one thing jumps out: the island's densest cluster of great Italian tables sits along the Wailea–Kihei corridor. Stay there and Ferraro's, Matteo's, Longhi's, Manoli's, and both Fabiani's locations are all within a ten-minute drive — several within walking distance of Wailea's resort path — while Casanova and Marlow slot neatly into an Upcountry day.

Our Luxe Maui Properties rentals across Wailea, Kihei, and Ma'alaea are built for eaters: full kitchens for market-night cooking, wine fridges and lanai tables for the takeout evenings, and a local team happy to tell you which night Ferraro's has the best musicians. We'll even make the case for which carbonara wins — though you should really run that experiment yourself.

Browse our Wailea & South Maui rentals →

Quick Reference: Maui Italian at a Glance

• Splurge oceanfront: Ferraro's Bar e Ristorante, Four Seasons Wailea — book sunset seating weeks ahead

• Chef-owned & wine-focused: Matteo's Osteria, Wailea — house-made pasta, deep Italian wine list

• Old-school classic: Longhi's, Shops at Wailea — Maui's Italian-influenced original since the '70s era

• Casual & family-run: Fabiani's Bakery & Pizza, Kihei and Wailea Gateway — bakery mornings, pizza nights, great takeout

• Pizza with a view: Manoli's Pizza Company, Wailea — hand-tossed pies and a reliable happy hour

• Worth the drive: Casanova (Makawao), Marlow (Pukalani), Taverna (Kapalua) — fold into an Upcountry or west-side day

• Home base: Wailea–Kihei corridor puts every South Maui spot within ten minutes — and gives you a kitchen for pasta night

Maui will never pretend to be Italy — the ocean's too warm, the fish is too fresh, and nobody's rushing you out of your table. But that's exactly why Italian food works so well here: sunshine cooking in a place with better sunsets. Buon appetito, island-style.

Get personalized recommendations →